Reprinted from the Proceedings of the NAT~NAL. ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, Vol. 32, No. 6, pp. 183-1'73. June, 1946 RE VERSE-MUTA TION AND ADAPTATION IN LE UCINELESS NE UROSPORA BYFRANCIS J. RYANANDJOSHUA LEDERBERG DEPARTYENTOPZO~~LOGYANDCOLLEGEOPPHYSICIANSANDSURGEONS. COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY Communicated April 6. 1946 Mutations affecting specific steps in biochemical syntheses have been produced in Neurospora crassa by x-rays and ultra-violet radiation.' In crosses with wild-type molds, these mutations segregate in a Mendelian fashion and hence involve the alteration of single determinant factors. Since many of the mutants seem to completely lack a specific synthetic ability it was not certain whether they involved small chr6mosomal aber- rations such as deficiencies, or the inactivation of genes which still self- duplicate. Up to the present time no demonstration of back-mutation, which would afford indirect e'vidence on this question, has been made for any of the biochemical mutanks of Neurospora. On the basis of the evi- dence presented below we conclude that reverse-mutation to the wild-type allele does occur. Strain 33757, which originated from a culture treated with ultra-violet light, is unable to synthesize the amino acid, leucine, an inability which has been shown by Regnery2 to be caused by a difference from wild type in a single factor. In the course of the development of an assay method for leucine by the use of strain 33757 it was noted that the weights of some cul- tures were unusually high and did not bear the typical relationship to leucine in the medium which characterizes the growth of this mutant strain. The phenomenon was called adaptation.3 Genetic and physiological studies have been made on three independently adapted strains of 33757.' Adapted strains 01 and /3 were derived as follows from a leucineless albino- marked stock of mating type A (33757-4637-A). Conidia were inoculated into flasks containing 0.25 mg. 1 (+) leucine per 50-ml. medium and were incubated at 3O'C. for P/2 days. Samples were taken from two cultures which subsequently proved to have unusually high weights, and inoculated into minimal medium. From this time, adapted cultures (Y and /3 were 164 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG PR0C.N. A. S. subcultured on minimal medium where they grew like wild type. The third adapted strain, y, was obtained from a salmon-colored leucineless stock of mating type a (33757-a) which was heavily inoculated into minimal medium. In one instance growth was observed and, upon subculturing, this adapted strain was prototrophic6 and grew like wild type. It should be emphasized that marker genes, for color and for mating type, were not modified in the course of adaptation. Furthermore, among more than 150 adaptations of the leucineless albino stock which we have ob- served in our studies, none.have shown pigmentation. Consequently it is concluded that the adapted strains did not arise through contamination. Genetic Studies.-In order to test the presumption that adaptation in- volves a genie mutation, the adapted cultures were first crossed with a leucineless strain of the opposite mating type. Asci were dissected and the spores allowed to germinate on medium containing leucine. The resulting strains were then tested for their ability to grow on minimal medium. The results are given in table 1. TABLE 1 CIIARAC+ERISTICS OP~I CULTURES OBTAINED BY THE GERMINATION OF SPORES DISSECTED IN ORDER FROM WHOLE ASCI SECURED FROM CROSSES OF LEUCINELESS-ADAPTED BY LEUCINELESS ., CP.OSt3 -a x 33757-a- . B x 33757-a . y X 33757-4637-A- ' OROWTHC GROWTH GROWra oaowra ON ON ON ON SPORE MINIM*L MINIbiAI. ?dIINIY*I. ?dIAIYAL NO. couxb YBDIUM COLOR YBDI~M COLOR MEDIUM COl.OP YBDlIfY 1 - + + + - + - 2 - + + + - + + 3 + + + + 4 + + + + + - - ; + - d 6 + - ._.- I -I- - +' 6 + - - - - + + + 7 - + - - - + + - 8 - + - - - + - + a This ascus was not dissected in order. ' + refers to salmon conidial pigment, - to albino. ' + refers to growth, - to failure to grow. All strains grew on medium to which . leucine was added. d This spore did not germinate. In view of the 1: 1 ratios obtained in these asci, leucine-independence in' the adap$ed strains must be due to a chromosomal and not a non-Mende- lian cytoplasmic factor. Thesecrosses do not, however, supply any informa- tion about the relationship of the leucineless locus in strain 33757, Z1, to the gene for leucine-independence, L. The demonstration of this relationship depends on. crosses made be- tween prototrophic strains from the fi and wild type. In performing this cross, the fi was used rather than the parent adapted strain to avoid the PROC. N. A.S. wild type. The Aored leucineless ited into minimal Ion subculturing, we. i for mating type, Lore, among more nch we have ob- :onseque,ntly it.@ contamination. it adaptation in- t crossed with a dissected and the 2. The resulting ~1 medium. The ::- i: :, j /': ,.,'~ :,'jj, .': ZION OF SPORES :ROSSBS O+ _ ,: -. : 3. .::/, i 3. `, > ;-j : : :i !K e " ..hj,!-~! -independence- iii' )t a non-Mender `ply any in.forma~-. L 33757, l~,-to't.he: `. . . . . . . `ri I,.. losses made `be: performing .this ain to avoid the . VOL. 32, 1916 GENETICS: RYANANDLEDERBERG 16.5 confusion that might arisei from the heterocaryotic6 persistence of leucine- less nuclei in the adapted culture. Barring mutation, a culture derived from a single ascospore is genetically homogeneous. The spores secured from these crosses are classified in table 2. The most extensive test was performed on the progeny of /3 where there were 13 asci in which every spore germinated, 5 asci in which at, least one member of all four pairs of . spores germinated so that each of the 4 chromatids could be accounted for, 66 spores from asci with incomplete germination and S3 spores isolated at random. In addition some data were secured on the progeny of crosses between wild-type and the prototrophic fi strains secured from cr and y. A total of 300 single-spore cultures was examined and every one proved to be prototrophic. c .* TABLE 2 CLASSIFICATIOS OF THE ORIGIN OF SINGLE-SPORE CULTURES FROM CROSSES OF PROTOTROPHK~, CULTURES WITH WILD TYPE. ALL CULTURES PROVED TO BE LEUCIZE-INDEPENDENT No. OP ASCI No. OP WrrR *LT. No. OP No. OF ASCI CHROJI*IIDS SPORES SPORES (S?$ y=; 1) WAOSE 8 ACCO"NTED PROM ISOLATBD WILD SPORES FOR INCOXPL.ETE *T caoss cm X TYPE GERXINATED (4-7 SPORES) ASC1 RAXDOX p x33757-u (spore 1) 15300-A 0 3 10 0 P X 33757-u (spore 2) 15300-A 1 0 1 0 j3 X33757-u (spore 3) 15300-A 12 2 47 53 13 X 33757-a (spore i) 15300-A 0 0 s 0 a X 33757-u (spore 2) 15300-A 0 4 2 0 y X33757-4637-A (spore 43-14-A 0 3 0 isolated - - - - at random) TOTAL . 13 12 73 83 If leucine-independence in the adapted leucineless strains were due to mutation at a locus distinct from Ii, crosses between adapted and wild- , type strains should have had in their progeny a recombination class of leucineless. In the 25 asci and among the Madditional spores listed in 1s table 2 there were no recombinations. Since these numbers test for 1W 1v chances for recombination, of which none were fulfilled, the genes involved are probably alleles. Physiological Stzldies.-The physiological behavior of the adapted strains confirms the hypothesis of reverse mutation. The rate of progression of the adapted strains and their prototrophicfi progeny on an agar surface is the same as that of wild-type strains' from which they were originally derived (table 3)._ The addition of leucine did not stimulate or retard growth in either case. After S1/l clays in 30 ml. of liquid medium containing 1 per cent sucrose, wild-type strain l-A, albino strain 4637-A and adapted 166 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG PROC. N. A. s. strain /3 gave mycelial crops weighing between 109 and 114 mg. Thus, in their growth, as in their genetic behavior, leucineless-adapted cultures are indistinguishable from wild type. They probably represent back-mutations of the Z1 locus to the wild-type allele. TABLE 3 RATE OF GROWTFI IN MM. PER HR. OF LEUCINELESS-ADAPTED COMPARED WITH THAT OF WILD TVPE AT 25oC. EACH RATE Is THE AVERAGE OF MEASUREMENTS ON Two GROWTH TUBES ----MINIMM. AGAR SUPPLEMENTAD WITH- 7.5 y I( +) LEUCINE 2 MO. dl LBUCINE STR*IN 0 PER ML. PER ML. L-A 4.3 4.1 4.2 R977-a 4.0 . . . . 4637-A 4.1 . 15300-A 4.4 4.2 ; 4.2 4.4 4.3 4.2 4.1 4.2 Leucine-independent spore 1 from f, of ~3 (see table 1) 4.2 4.2 4.3 Are the Mutations Induced?-In ord.cr to determine whether the back- mutations were induced an examin8tion was lnatle of the frequency of adaptation in liquid medium containing various amounts of leucine. Adaptations were identified by the arbitrary method previously described.3 Those cultures which possessed unusually hi@ weights, more than 3a above the mean of the other members of a series, were classified as adapted. The data are shown in table 4. The frequency of adaptations depended not only upon the temperature but was higher in low leucine concentrations than in high leucine concentrations. Both of these differences are signifi- cant by x2 test. Since the dependence upon leucine concentration appears to be an example of chemically induced mutation it is important to examine closely the events that take place during the 81/z-day period. TABLE 4 EFFECT OF LEUCINE CONCENTRATION ON THE FREQUENCY OF ADAPTATIONS OF 33757-4637-A DURING 81/* DAPS IN 50.ML. LIQUID MEDIUM TEYP: 25oc.--- 3ooc. No. OP No. OF % No. OP No. OF % Av. % Id& I(+)LLUCINE CULTURES ADtaT& ADAP+*TION CULTURES ADAPT.&- ADAPTATION ADAPTATICIN TIONS TIONS 1.00 40 0 0 20 0 0 0 0.75 40 1 3 20 3 15 7 0.50 40 0 0 20 3 15 5 0.25 40 3 8 20 5 25 73 Av. y0 adaptation 3 14 The leucine concentration expressed in table 4 is the initial concentration. As growth proceeds, the medium is depleted of leucine by the mold. When VOL. 32. 1946 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG 167 the final weight is reached, bioassay of the medium proves the exhaustion of leucine. The medium will, at that time, support the growth of wild type Neurospom, or of leucineless Neurospora if further leucine is added. Thus, leucine alone is exhausted. The time at which this takes place depends upon the initial leucine concentration. On 0.25 mg. of 2 (+) leucine the final weight of about 7.5 mg. is attained in about 3 days. On 1.00 mg. I (+) leucine almost 6 days are required for the development of the final weight of 37 mg. During these times the mass of mycelium is increasing and with it, presumably, the, number of nuclei in which back-mutation has a chance to occur. In order to minimize the importance of the difference in time a long-term experiment was designed in which cultures of 33757-4637-A started their growth on 0.25 and 0.5 mg. I (+) leucine per 50 ml. at 30oC. The fre- quency of adaptation was observed between 6 and 45 days after inoculation, during which time all cultures were. exposed to subthreshold leucine con- centrations. Table 5 shows' the results obtained. The same criterion was TABLE 5 EFFECT OF LEUCINE CONCENTRATION ON THE FREQUENCY OF ADAPTATIONS OF 33757-4637-A BETWEEN 6 AND 45 DAYS IN 50-ML. LIQUID MEDIUM AT 30oC. No. OP No. C-II UG. I(+)L&UcINB % CULTTJRBS hDAPTATIONS *D*PTATION 0.50 43 5 12 0.25 38 16 42 used for identification of adaptations. It will be observed that even during this period there is a significantly higher frequency of adaptation in the cultures which began to grow in the presence of low leucine concentrations. Indeed, the frequency is so high that the average weight of all cultures. adapted and non-adapted, is higher (25 mg.) in the 0.25 mg. leucine series than in the 0.50 mg. leucine series (20 mg.). On the spontaneous mutation hypothesis one would expect the number of adaptations to be greater in those cultures with the higher nuclear populations, the high leucine series. We find the reverse to be true-the frequency of adaptations is an inverse function of mycelial mass. The orthodox viewpoint is that adaptive mutations are not directed by the environment of the cell but occur in a given percentage of the popula- tion per unit time, and may be selected by the environment. We have shown that adaptation, in this instance, is a mutation phenomenon. Thus far we have assumed that when a mutation to leucine-independence takes place it will be regularly selected for in the absence of leucine and result in an adaptation. However, this is not the case. Although adaptations are the result of mutation, every mutation does not yield an adaptation as the evidence presented below will indicate. . 168 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG PROC. N. A. S. Heterocaryons.-When a back-mutation occurs in a leucineless myce- lium and the mutated nucleus multiplies a heterocaryon6 is formed con- sisting of a mixture of leucineless and wild-type nuclei. The phenomenon of selection in such heterocaryons was studied by artificially preparing heterocaryons between leucineless and prototrophic strains and growing them on different concentrations of leucine. Figure 1 shows the behavior of a heterocaryon between the adapted strain /3, and the leucineless strain, 33757-4637-A, which gave rise to it. Growth was measured on the sur- face of agar in growth tubes containing no leucine. The leucineless strain showed, of course, no growth. The prototrophic fi control grew at the 200. o HETEROKARYON I X PROTOTROPHIC f, 0 HETEROKARYON 2 0 LEUCINELESS c---0-0~0 I 2 3 4 DAYS FIGURE 1 Growth rate of a heterocaryon of leucineless and adapted Neurospora on minimal medium. wild-type rate of 4.2 mm./hr. The heterocaryon grew at exactly the same rate, as though the wild-type nuclei it contained had outgrown the leucine- less nuclei. On medium containing a limiting concentration of leucine the prototrophic fr control still grew at a rate of 4~2 mm./hr. (Fig. 2). However, the heterocaryon grew at the same rate as the leucineless strain, 2.2 mm./hr. It appears as though the wild-type nuclei failed to outgrow the leucineless in the presence of a limiting leucine concentration. In other words, on minimal medium the heterocaryon grows like wild type but in the presence of leucine it grows like leucineless. To prove that such behavior would be characteristic of hyphae known to be heterocaryotic, minimal agar plates were inoculated with a mixture of leucim3ess 33757-4637-A and of adapted strains cr or /3. After the my- celium had grown over an area ca. 4 cm. in diameter, tips of single hyphae . VOL. 32. 1946 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG 169 were isolated6 and transferred to media containing or lacking leucine. The plate from which these isolations were made was also kept for further observation. Hyphae isolated to minimal medium continued to grow (as did the parent mycelium on the agar plate) demonstrating that they con- tained nuclei of the adapted genotype. Since hyphal tips were transferred at random, such nuclei must also have been present in those hyphae inocu- lated into tubes of leucine-containing medium. The conidia formed in these tubes, however, did not grow when tested on minimal medium. Therefore, in the presence of leucine, hyphae which originally contained some leucine-independent nuclei gave rise to conidia which were purely z . I 2 3 DAYS FIGURE 2 Growth rate of a heterocaryon of leucineless and adapted Neurospora on a limiting concentration of 1 (f) leucine (0.0075 mg./ml.). leucineless. Such behavior was characteristic of combinations of leucine- less with wild-type strains obtained independently of the leucineless muta- tion. The similarity of adapted and wild-type strains in this respect is further evidence for the identity of the adapted and wild-type strains at the L locus. This phenomenon is under further study but the following evidence may be reported briefly here. Hyphae were isolated in a similar manner from heterocaryons in which the leucineless and wild-type nuclei bore different marker-genes for conidial color. Such heterocaryotic hyphae behaved similarly to those described above. Furthermore, whenever a leucineless culture was selected from a heterocaryon, the color markers of the wild type could not be demonstrated. *This is in favor of the hypothesis that 170 GENETICS: RYAN A ND LEDERBERG PROC. N. A. S. the wqd-type nuclei in such combinations were selected against in the pres- ence of leucine. The disappearance of color markers which characterized leucineless nuclei demonstrated a selection in favor of wild type when heterocaryons were grown on minimal medium. However, in some in- stances when heterocaryons were studied in growth tubes on minimal medium, they grew like wild type for a time but then slowed down and sometimes stopped (Fig. 1). This behavior helps to interpret the results of the long-term growth experiment in liquid medium. In liquid cultures when a back-mutation to leucine independence occurs and a heterocaryon is formed the independent nuclei may overgrow and form a complete adaptation. On the other hand, the heterocaryon may be- gin to grow and then stop as the back-mutated nuclei are inactivated by the leucineless. This behavior was repeatedly observed during growth in liquid medium. In a culture which had reached the maximum growth for its leucine level a new patch of growini mycelium often appeared on the surface of the cl0 t. This new growth may continue and overgrow the whole culture, or, after its initiation, it may stop, forming what was previ- ously termed a "partial" adaptatjotl.3 Presumably we were observing heterocaryon selection. The interpretation we offer for the higher frequency of adaptation in low leucine concentrations is in terms of the size of the mycelial mass involved rather than directly in terms of the leucine content of the medium. The greater the mycelial mass, the larger the population of leucineless nuclei in the midst of which a leucine-independent nucleus arises by wutation and the greater the chance that this mutant nucleus will be inactivated. Al- though we cannot duplicate directly the introduction of a single leucine- independent nucleus into a leucineless mycelium we have studied the growth of heterocaryons in liquid medium. l?igure 3 shows the weights assumed after S'/Z days by a heterocaryon of /3 itid 33757-4337-A and by 33757-4637-A on different leucine concentrations. As the leucine concentration rises the amount of rnycelium, and hence the number of leucineless nuclei, similarly increases. However, the final weight of the heterocaryon decreases with leucine concentration. Ap- . parently the greater the number of leucineless nuclei the more rapidly the leucine-independent nuclei are inactivated and the sooner growth ceases. These experiments, then, provide evidence for our interpretation of the frequency of adaptations on different leucine concentrations. An adapta- tion is due to the growth of leucine-independent nuclei which arose by mutation but whether the increased growth will be significant depends upon whether conditions favor the lnactivat ion of the leucine-independent nuclei. Large mycelial masses with many leucineless nuclei are more unfavorable for escape of the prototrophic growth than small mycelial masses. We do not believe that our experiments allow any conclusion as to the rBle of VOL. 32,1946 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG 171 leucine in the induction of mutation at this locus. Such mutations prob- ably occur spontaneously but their expression depends upon the leucine content of the environment through its effect on mycelial mass. Discuss&-Because of the heterocaryon selection the back-mutation of locus 2i is not a favorable object for the study of mutation rates. For example, the effect of temperature shown in table 4 may be due to its in- fluence either on the mutation rate or on the selection efficiency or both. Any calculation of mutation rate would yield a minimum value, at best, be- cause many, if not most, mutations can never express themselves as adaptn- tions because of the rapid inactivation of mutant leucine-independent nuclei. 40 . 0 HETEROKARYON I Cl LEUCINELESS 0 I LOG, LEUCINE CONCENTRATION MG. 50 ML / FIGURE 3 Final growth of a hetcrocaryon of leucineless and adapted IC'eurospora on different concentrations of I (+) leucine in liquid medium at 25" C. On the basis of the selection phenomenon it is to be expected that back- mutations of locus II would not persist in stock cultures maintained on leucine. This probably explains the fact that in our experience no culture in stock tubes has ever adapted. Likewise in nature the heterocaryon selection phenomenon may help to maintain mutant types. . In bacteria nutritional mutants are known to adapt and lose their re- quirement.a In this way they seem to gain a new function. In the light 172 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG PROC. N. A. S. of recent evidence it is conceivable that nutritional mutants in bacteria are formed by an inactivation of a gene.g From this state it may later back- mutate. We conceive of this process in Neurospora as follows : mutation L, ' 11 back- mutation The wild-type allele, L, is present in the wild-type stock and controls some step in the synthesis of leucine. Under the influence of ultra-violet light, or otherwise, I" this gene can mutate to the inactive state, 21. We conceive that, where L makes an active enzyme involved in leucine syn- thesis and self-dul)licntcs as well, II is also self-duplicating and could possibly make a "tlefective enzyme." The self-duplicating inactive gene 11 spontaneously back-mutates to L.. We believe it to be established, with a fair degree of certainty, that the leucineldss mutation in Neurosporu, II, is not a chromosomal rearrangement or deficiency but a modification of a gene to a still self~duplicating particle." S~mz~~avy.- The leucincless mutant of Nc~ro.sporu is a true gene mutation. The adaptation to leucine--irldcpentletlce, which this mutant sometimes undergoes, is due to back-mutation to the wild-type condition at the leu- cineless locus. This is demonstrated by the genetic behavior of the adapted strain in crosses with leucineless and by the genetic behavior of the leucine- independentfl progeny in crosses with wild type. iLloreover, the adapted and wild-type strains are physiologically identical. The incidence of adaptations is significantly higher in the presence of low concentrations of leucine than in the presence of high concentrations. This apparent chemical induction of mutations has its explanation in the fact that a back-mutation in the leucineless strain always results in the formation of a heterocaryon. In a heterocaryon between the leucineless and the adapted or wild-type strains, the leucineless nuclei have an ad- vantage in the presence of leucine. Whether a back-mutation will result in an adaptation depends upon whether conditions favor selection against the leucine-independent nuclei. 1 Beadle, G. W., Physiol. Rev., 2.5,643~663 (1945); Beadle, G. W., and Tatum, E. L., Am. Jour. Bat., 32, 678-686 (1945). z Regnery, D. C., Jour. Biol. &em., 154, 151-160 (1944). 3 Ryan, F. J., and Brand, E., Ibid., 154, 161-175 (1944). ' The experimental procedures used in these studies have been described previously. See references 1 ant1 3 a11t1 Ryan, F. J.. Beadle, G. W., anrl Tatum, E. L., Am. Jour. But., 30, 784-799 (19.13). 6 We propose to designate as a prototroph any strain which has the Imtritiond requirements of the "wild type" from which it was derived irrespective of how it became VOL. 32,1946 GENETICS: RYAN AND LEDERBERG 173 prototrophic. (For Neurospora crasxa see Butler, E. T., Robbins, W. J., and Dodge, B. 0.. Science, 94, 262 (1941).) (i Beadle, G. W., and Coonradt, V. L., Genclics, 29, 291-308 (1944). r Different "wild-type" stocks undoubtedly carry gene differences which can modify such physiological characteristics as growth rate and degree of conidiation.* These differences may segregate to different stocks. Therefore, it is not strictly correct to speak of the wild type as an entirely distinctive genotype. However, in every mutant studied the nutritional requirement is detemlined by a single gene, although the genetic background may, to a certain extent, modify the details of its expression. It would be desirable to use "isogenic" strains, obtained by repeated back-crossing, but the biparental inheritance of Neurospora makes very difficult the elimination of any gene differences that may be linked to mating-type alleles. * Roepke, R. R., Libby, R. L., and Small, M. H., Jour. Bact., 48, 401-412 (1944). s Gray, C. H., and Tatum, E. L., these PROCEEDINGS, 30, 404-410 (1944). lo The leucineless mutant, 33757, was obtained from a culture of Neurospora which had been treated with ultra-violet radiation. However, since parallel studies on spon- taneous mutation were not carried out' it cannot be proved that the mutation L -+ Z, was induced and did not occur spontaneously. I1 Strain 4637-A is known to carry a translocation (McClintock, B., Am. Jour. Bat.. 32, 671-678 (1945)) which is closely linked to albino. It reduces crossing over in a region of the sex chromosome (Doermann, A. H., Arch. Biochem., 5, 373-384 (1944)). The prototrophic fi strain used in these experiments, although wild type in color, may have carried the translocation. The adaptation could have been due to mutation to leucine independence at a locus other than Ii since, in the cross of thefi with wild type, reduction of crossing over might have prevented the appearance of recombinatlons. There are two types of evidence which militate against these assumptions. First, we found no reason to believe that the fi by wild-type cross produced the lethal classes which would be expected if a translocation were involved. Second, the physiological identity of adapted strains with wild type speaks for the identity of the leucine-inde- pendent gene and the wild-type allele of 11.