Follow Profiles in Science on Pinterest!
The Oswald T. Avery Collection
Quicktime Audio (2,221,680 Bytes)
- [Rene Dubos's memories of working in Oswald Avery's laboratory]
RealMedia Audio (554,708 Bytes)
- Running Time:
- 4 minutes, 37 seconds
- 1979-02-02 (February 2, 1979)
- Dubos, Rene J.
- Rockefeller University
- Reproduced with permission of Rockefeller University.
- Medical Subject Headings (MeSH):
- Transformation, Genetic
- History of Medicine
- Exhibit Category:
- After the Discovery: The Transforming Principle's Reception by the Scientific Community
- Symposium Celebrating the Thirty-Fifth Anniversary of the Publication of 'Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance
Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types' (February 2, 1979)
- Box Number:
- Unique Identifier:
- Document Type:
- Sound recordings
- Oral histories
- Physical Condition:
- Series: Commentary on Avery and His Work, 1944-2005
- SubSeries: Audiovisuals
- Folder: 35th Anniversary of DNA Publication, 1979
- Now in 1928 there occurred in Great Britain, a discovery that was terribly upsetting to all of us, and especially to Dr. Avery.
Namely, an officer of the British Ministry of Health, Fred Griffith, demonstrated to his satisfaction, through very crude
experiments in mice, that those pneumococcus types, that all of us were so convinced were so stable, were, in reality, could
be changed from one to the other in the bodies of mice. These experiments were extremely complicated; technically, they were
not terribly convincing, except that Fred Griffith was a person of such technical mastery that one had to take notice of it.
Well, we took notice of it. We had countless discussions in the laboratory about the possibility that specific pneumococcus
types could change one into the other. But Dr. Avery could not accept it. It went too much against all that he had taught
for ten or 15 years, and too much against the achievements of his laboratory. So that, we did not repeat the experiments
of Fred Griffith, even though we were fully aware of them. [Avery] left for his summer vacation in 1929, going to Deer Isle
in Maine, where he went every summer, and I stayed in the laboratory as I did in those days, and if I mention myself, it is
not for my participation in the problem, it is that I was witness in the experiments and participated a bit in the experiments
which confirmed Griffith's studies, here, on the 6th floor of the hospital.
- I shared the laboratory with a Canadian, a Canadian physician who took care of patients suffering from lobar pneumonia, but
who also worked in the laboratory, as we all did in that time. Now, Henry Dawson was a Canadian, he was a British Canadian,
very important. And he was absolutely convinced that anything done in England had to be right [laughter]. And I can assure
you this, I am not trying to play with this fact. He was intensely [emotional?] about it. Because he was so [emotional?]
about it, he decided he would try to repeat the experiments, during the summer, that's the time during which I participated
in the experiments with him, and he actually duplicated Griffith's results. If I mention this it is to convey to you
that in scientific life there are all sorts of human elements that are not sufficiently recognized. I think it would not
be confirmed in our laboratory if Henry Dawson had not been a British Canadian. So he did repeat the experiment, and very
soon he did what Griffith had not been able to do. He showed that the transformation of the pneumococcus types could occur
not only in the mouse, through very messy, complicated experiments, but could be done in the test tube, and this was an achievement
of phenomenal importance, for it meant that from then on it could be studied by all sorts of techniques.
- Metadata Last Modified Date:
U.S. National Library of Medicine, 8600 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20894
National Institutes of Health,
Department of Health & Human Services