Skip to main contentU.S. National Library of MedicineU.S. National Library of Medicine


Profiles in Science
   
Pinterest badge Follow Profiles in Science on Pinterest!

The Oswald T. Avery Collection

Title:
Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg pdf (82,210 Bytes) transcript of pdf
Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg
Description:
One of several letters in which Coburn responded to requests by Lederberg for his recollections of Avery and Griffith. In this letter, Coburn compared the similarities between the two scientists' personalities.
Number of Image Pages:
1 (82,210 Bytes)
Date:
1966-04-20 (April 20, 1966)
Creator:
Coburn, Alvin F.
Recipient:
Lederberg, Joshua
Rights:
Reproduced with permission of the New York Medical College.
Copyright owned by the New York Medical College.
Subject:
Medical Subject Headings (MeSH):
History of Medicine
Exhibit Categories:
Shifting Focus: Early Work on Bacterial Transformation, 1928-1940
After the Discovery: The Transforming Principle's Reception by the Scientific Community
Relation:
Metadata Record Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Oswald T. Avery (May 25, 1943) pdf (114,106 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCBDBG.pdf
Metadata Record [Fred Griffith and "Bobby"] [1936] jpg (45,270 Bytes)
/ps/access/CCAABN_.jpg
Metadata Record Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg (September 28, 1965) pdf (44,226 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCAAGS.pdf
Metadata Record [Oswald T. Avery] [March 1943] jpg (16,160 Bytes)
/ps/access/CCAAFU_.jpg
Metadata Record [Avery with Alvin Coburn's son, Tim] [March 1943] jpg (121,440 Bytes)
/ps/access/CCAABZ_.jpg
Metadata Record Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg (November 9, 1965) pdf (154,563 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCAAGU.pdf
Metadata Record Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg (November 19, 1965) pdf (151,809 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCAAIW.pdf
Metadata Record Letter from Alvin F. Coburn to Joshua Lederberg (March 21, 1966) pdf (36,787 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCAAGV.pdf
Metadata Record Letter from Joshua Lederberg to Alvin F. Coburn (April 1, 1966) pdf (53,956 Bytes) transcript of pdf
/ps/access/CCAAGW.pdf
Box Number: 4
Folder Number: 6
Unique Identifier:
CCAAIX
Document Type:
Letters (correspondence)
Language:
English
Format:
application/pdf
image/tif
Physical Condition:
Good
Series: Commentary on Avery and His Work, 1944-2005
SubSeries: Chronological
Folder: 1964-1969
Transcript:
April 20, 1966
Dear Doctor Lederberg,
My delay in answering your letter of April 1 is due to a lack of competence to deal with your inquiry. Yesterday, I had lunch with Dr. Rene Dubos at the Rockefeller "University". He was in agreement with both the remarks made in your 1955 reprint and also with your suggestion that the "intellectual history of the interaction of these men" should be written up. However, I well know that I am not the person to do it. In my opinion, nobody could do this more effectively and gracefully than Rene Dubos.
Actually, interviews with about four persons could supply all facts essential for writing up the proposed bit of history. My guess is that Fred Griffith thought little of his experiment. The concept of pragmatism in the British Ministry of Health at that time was quite different from that of the Rockefeller Institute. On the other hand, there is no doubt in my mind of "how deeply Avery understood the genetic implications". Not only were his restraint and modesty exceptional, but his vision and insight were phenomenal. The sudden cessation of Avery's work was due to the Cupid's Arrow. An invaluable assistant, Miss Harriet Taylor, suddenly left his laboratory for Europe to become Mrs. Ephrussi.
One of the extraordinary aspects of the Griffith-Avery story is that the two men were so similar in many respects. This would impress anybody who knew them both.
To my way of thinking, it will be refreshing for future biologists to learn how Avery's mind rejected Griffith's work at first. It was a "foreign body", not to be assimilated. But Avery's mind was not closed. Avery had a deep respect for Griffith and when Avery satisfied himself that Griffith was right, he began his attack on the problem. As you well know, this was gentle, catholic and devastating to preconceived ideas.
It will be good to learn your reactions to my suggestion that Rene Dubos do the needful. All the best
Sincerely,
Alvin F. Coburn, M.D.
Assistant Dean and Professor of Microbiology
Metadata Last Modified Date:
2013-04-25
Linked Data:
RDF/XML     JSON     JSON-LD     N3/Turtle     N-Triples